In Chapter 14: The Future of the Groundswell in Groundswell, authors Li and Bernoff describe a fictional day in the life of a shoe company marketer, giving examples of how tapping into the groundswell could be used make better business decisions.
While the story is nice and illustrates what may work with social media when everything goes well, I had a bit of trouble suspending my disbelief, as things at work are rarely that easy (as much as we wish them to be).
However, it did lead me to wonder about what it takes to be a social media marketer, especially regarding handling professional-personal life balance and motivation.
Although that shoe marketer story mentions dropping off the grid at lunchtime, I suspect that in many cases being involved in social media means that you need to be available 24-7 as you never know what will happen. Granted, you may be able to trade off that "on-call" responsibility with another team member. However because you're responsible for monitoring the pulse of the groundswell, it means you're constantly keeping tabs on things at night and on weekends as social media doesn't slow down then (if anything, it may bump up higher then). Plus you often have to tie a personal social media account to a work one, which means that notifications from work-related items get mixed in with your personal ones.Could working in social media decrease the enjoyment of using the medium, as it switches from personal use to it being a job?
I happened upon two articles recently that relate to motivation. Although they focus on different topics, quantifying personal data and executive compensation, the underlying concepts are applicable to social media professionals.
The Hidden Cost of Personal Quantification study (in the Journal of Consumer Research) looked at the effect of quantifying personal data on behavior, such as the use of fitness trackers. While this quantification does seem to promote increase in the tracked behavior, it can also reduce people's intrinsic motivation and enjoyment of the activity. So if you already enjoy doing something, tracking data about it may actually make you enjoy it less, as it changes your motivation from being intrinsic (coming internally from oneself) to more extrinsic (having an external source). If your motivation is already extrinsic, then using quantifiable data may help you to reach your goals.
This study also made me think about the Generation Like documentary, especially the group of kids setting up a friend's social media profile and discussing and comparing number of likes. It sets up a situation where self-esteem is measured by quantity of friends, likes, followers, and views - all extrinsic motivation. This extrinsic motivation affects self-presentation and commodifies friendship (i.e. if you like me, I'll like you in exchange).
The other article, Stop Paying Executives for Performance, in the Harvard Business Review advocates that top managers should receive fixed salaries, instead of performance-based incentives, based on motivation research. They point out that "contingent pay only works for routine tasks"; whereas for creative tasks, variable pay hurts performance. Incentive-based situations promote extrinsic motivation and decreases intrinsic motivation to do something with a genuine interest to learn. Creativity and innovation are best fueled by intrinsic motivation. When people are fixated on targeted goal instead instead of acting from desire to learn, it can often weaken performance, cause people to neglect other areas, and even lead to making unethical decisions to achieve a goal.
Social media marketing definitely requires creativity to consistently come up with ideas and present them in engaging way. Practitioners need to to be innovative, agile, and open to a certain amount of risk. Metrics and analytics are embedded in most social media platforms to track performance. Looking at trends and trying to understand them may help to figure out what may work best in the future. However, it's likely that setting specific performance goals (such as hitting 150K likes) with accountability could be detrimental to encouraging innovative thought processes to actually meet those goals.
Social media marketing is still a developing field. Most people start social media use on a personal level. Some participants may be more intrinsically motivated, wanting to share their creativity and knowledge, learning and connecting with others. Others may be more more extrinsically motivated, using social media for self-image, validation, and because everyone else is there. There is a spectrum of motivation, which may change over time and based on the situation.
So I ask you, digital natives, do you think your enjoyment of social media will change if/when your focus switches from using it personally to professionally?



For me I do not use social media as much as many people my age do. However, the amount I do use it becomes quite tiring when I am on it to much. So I would say that I would become tired and frustrated with my job if I had to keep tabs on social media 24/7. I think companies like, Hootsuite, have become close to finding an effective way people can post but also have that time to also enjoy the world around them. Do I see myself at a long term job where I have to update the social media sites...maybe not, but I won't know until I have tried.
ReplyDelete